Monday, May 11, 2015

Entry #7 Dumb Men

     The blog "Dumb Men" is dedicated to pointing out stereotypes and male-bashing for men in advertising. The layout it is pretty straightforward, though not very visually pleasing, and follows a basic format throughout the website. There are videos upon videos showing advertisements and then explanations about why they show stereotypes.

    Though I agreed with almost every stereotype the blog pointed out, I found that a few of them were a bit far fetched and trying too hard to make something big out of something that I personally didn't see as a huge deal. Is this blog trying to show negative stereotypes of men and why these are harmful? Or just be like, "look, men get exploited in advertisements too"? Or, "stereotypes for men are a real thing in advertisement"? I couldn't tell what the blog was trying to accomplish.

    Stereotypes are often a way for people to appeal to a larger audience, because many times stereotypes are based off of a general population of people and place whole groups of people into a broad category. In advertisement, something that is trying to appeal to as large of an audience as it can, I can see why companies would use stereotypes. However, I don't believe that companies should be making money off of reinforcing negative and inaccurate stereotypes, but sometimes we have to take what we see on television with a grain of salt.

    Plus, the way the blog words their posts in a way reinforces these stereotypes and is counter productive to what they're trying to accomplish (or at least what I think they're trying to accomplish). They refer to the men in the advertisements as "stupid men" or "dumb men" and in the process of trying to point out male-bashing they are using negative language that hurts their case. It would be one thing if they said something like "this particular advertisement depicts this man as a stupid husband that..." ect ect but instead they say "A stupid husband that...." ect ect and negatively references the men who are in the advertisement. The blog, in my opinion, should have been more conscious of how they worded their points that they're making.

     For example, in this video I linked to below, the blog is trying to point out how this AT&T ad shows a "stupid dad" stereotype. The caption on this advertisement is, "A stupid dad on the web gets the idea for a Bieber haircut, buys a matching slacker hoodie for his daugher and video chats with his daughter's boyfriend who he calls Broseph. His daughter gets annoyed and screams for her mom. The dad then mocks her for yelling for her mom and goes back to surfing the web. What a jerk."



    However, I think that the blog is delving a little too deep on this one. I think what the advertisement is trying to do is relate with teenagers who have a parent that tries to be "hip" and "with the times," but just ends up looking kind of silly. I know personally my dad will try to use slang and do things that are completely ridiculous just to embarrass me, so I found this advertisement relatable, in a way. It didn't make me think he was some "dumb guy," it reminded me of my own dad and how far fetched he can be at times. But not in a negative way, just in a "oh, haha, I know a lot of teenage girls who could probably relate with this." Just like in advertisements that are geared towards parents they stereotype teenagers as "rebellious punks" who don't listen or are always making a mess. Plus the caption doesn't leave any room for discussion or solutions to how stereotyping men has negative effects.

    This next advertisement could have really opened the door to a great discussion about how masculinity is perceived in advertisements and the negative effects it has on men. But instead the blog just captioned this, "Here is another Miller commercial where the bitchy bartender tells a guy to man up since he is not drinking Miller Lite. The skirt wearing man is emasculated and shamed in front of women for his beer selection. Men, think carefully while your contemplating your next beer purchase. Miller has defined manly for you so you aren't the fool wearing the skirt."

Wow. So profound (sarcasm).


 
  This advertisement has a lot in it that could have been discussed. But instead the blog didn't open up any points as to why this is a problem. Instead it refers to the lady in the advertisement as a "bitchy bartender" and the man as a "fool wearing the skirt," both of these are negative stereotypes for both genders and harm whatever it is the blog is trying to accomplish.

    There's a huge culture around what it means to "be a man" and men are pressured into trying to live up to this code of masculinity and anything they do that is perceived as even mildly feminine is ridiculed. That's the real problem in this advertisement, and in our society. And even after he "mans up" and loses the skirt (because that's obviously the worst thing a man can do, right? Wear women's clothing? This plays into transphobia, which is a huge problem that costs the lives of many men and women everywhere) he is still ridiculed because he can't do "anything right." This guy just can't win. And this not only is male-bashing, it hurts women too because it shows being feminine as weak and unacceptable.

    Even though I feel like this blog seriously lacked some crucial elements into effectively pointing out stereotypes in advertisement, it still did raise my awareness to the problems that men face, too. Both genders are exploited through advertisement and degraded into what society deems as "acceptable" and that's a real problem. It's easy to look past all that and ignore the deeper more harmful messages that advertisements are trying to give, but from now on I'm going to be more sensitive to those underlying statements made. Hopefully you will, too.

No comments:

Post a Comment